Nov 27, 2013; Tampa, FL, USA; Tampa Bay Lightning left wing Ondrej Palat (18) is congratulated by teammates after he scored a goal against the Philadelphia Flyers during the second period at Tampa Bay Times Forum. Mandatory Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Tampa Bay Lightning Dodge Dan Boyle Bandwagon Bullet


The news all over social media recently is that the New York Islanders have just traded a conditional fifth-round pick in the 2015 NHL Draft to the San Jose Sharks for Dan Boyle. The Isles have his rights and the ability to re-sign him. If Boyle cannot agree to terms with the Islanders, he will hit the free agent market.

Many of you in Bolt Nation remember Dan Boyle from the 2004 Stanley Cup Champions. Boyle was our top blue liner and was an integral part of the Lightning organization for seven years from 2001 until he was traded to San Jose during the 2008-09 season.

It seems that many Lightning fans were hoping that Boyle would make his way back to Tampa once word leaked a few weeks ago by San Jose GM Doug Wilson that the Sharks were not going to re-sign Boyle who will be an unrestricted free agent on July 1st. I was not one of those fans.

Now, don’t get me wrong, Boyle was a great player for the Bolts during his time here. Aside from Vincent Lecavalier who arrived in Tampa a few days before I did, Boyle’s was the only Lightning sweater I owned back in the day. He was one of the best defensemen in the entire NHL in bringing the puck up out of the defensive zone. The sad reality is that Boyle’s best days are behind him.

He can still play in the league but one glaring deficiency among the Lightning D-men that Montreal exposed in the playoff sweep this year was their lack of speed. So why bring in a defenseman who has clearly lost a step?

There is no question that Boyle is a leader in the locker room and with so many youngsters on the Lightning roster, it could make sense to bring in someone who has that veteran leadership. It just makes more sense to find a player who shores up a weakness, not make the weakness more glaring.

I wish Dan Boyle nothing but success with the Isles and hope he has a few good seasons with them. He’ll be 38 when the upcoming season begins and I think we need to get faster with our defense. Just like that Boyle jersey I bought over 10 years ago that doesn’t quite fit, neither will Boyle in the 2014-15 edition of the Tampa Bay Lightning.

Look at the teams that went to the conference finals this year. Montreal, New York Rangers, LA Kings and the Chicago Blackhawks. Now look at their top four D-men: you have names like Duncan Keith, Drew Doughty, P.K. Subban and Ryan McDonagh among others. These guys have speed to burn. The Lightning need to acquire speed on the blue line and simply put, Dan Boyle doesn’t fit that bill.

The Bolts finally have a bonafide #1 PRIME TIME goalie in Ben Bishop, why put a defenseman in front of him who is so clearly past his prime? I understand why some fans will be disappointed with my take here, but I say think with your heads, not your hearts. I would love Dan Boyle…… circa 2002-2005. Unfortunately, that guy was not available.

Tags: Dan Boyle Tampa Bay Lightning

  • Willow Rose

    You make some very good points. It is so very hard to think with our heads instead of our hearts sometimes. Teams have to do what they have to do to make themselves strong. But of course it’s the players that make the teams relatable to the fans. It’s important to trust the sports universe at times. Thank you for the reminder.

    • http://www.boltsbythebay.com Daniel Herrejon

      Believe me it pains me to take this stance on Boyle, he and Vinnie were my favorite players from the Cup team. Just want to see the team make the right moves because I think they are close to becoming contenders.